A single key next to a large bunch of different keys, illustrating one supplier instead of many

Single sourcing: just one supplier – when it saves money and when it gets risky

6 min read

In procurement, there are two camps. One says: consolidate, negotiate, simplify. The other says: never become dependent on a single supplier. Both are right. The only question is when.

This article explains what single sourcing is, where it pays off, where it becomes dangerous and why the answer for MRO parts is often different from that for direct materials.

Terms: single, sole, dual and multiple sourcing

The terms are often mixed up. A short overview helps:

  • Single sourcing: You deliberately choose one supplier, even though others exist.
  • Sole sourcing: There is only one supplier, for example because the manufacturer sells a part exclusively. You have no choice.
  • Dual sourcing: You split your demand between two suppliers.
  • Multiple sourcing: You buy from several suppliers and keep them in competition.

The difference between single and sole matters. Single sourcing is a strategy. Sole sourcing is a dependency.

The advantages of single sourcing

Less effort

Every supplier costs time. They have to be set up, evaluated, managed and paid. If you keep many suppliers for small quantities, you often pay more for the administration than for the goods.

Better terms

Consolidated volume creates bargaining power. That applies to prices, but also to payment terms, framework agreements and service levels.

Closer collaboration

A supplier who knows your plants, your processes and your contacts works faster. Queries become less frequent. So do mistakes.

Clear responsibility

If something goes wrong, there is exactly one point of contact. No discussion about who is responsible.

The risks of single sourcing

Dependency

If the supplier fails, through insolvency, fire, strike or a capacity bottleneck, the goods are missing. Building up an alternative source then takes time you do not have.

Complacency

Without competition, the pressure eases. Prices creep up, response times get longer. It rarely happens on purpose, but it happens.

Loss of knowledge

If you only know one route for years, you forget the others. In an emergency, you then lack the knowledge of where else to look.

Single sourcing is smart when your one supplier has many sources of its own.

The MRO difference: consolidating does not mean narrowing

With direct materials, single sourcing usually means one manufacturer for one component. If that manufacturer fails, production stops. With MRO, the situation is different. It is rarely about one component, but about thousands of items from hundreds of manufacturers.

If you rely on a single manufacturer here, you will not get far. But if you choose a sourcing partner that buys across manufacturers, you only consolidate the interface, not the sources. You have one point of contact. Behind it stand many suppliers.

This is the core of what procurement calls supplier consolidation. The risk shifts in the process: away from the individual source and towards the question of how resilient the partner itself is.

Typical scenario: the supplier list that grew over time

A medium-sized plant has collected suppliers over decades. Every new maintenance technician brought their contacts, every new machine its manufacturer, every emergency another distributor. Today the supplier list is longer than the staff list. Many suppliers receive only one or two orders a year.

Procurement wants to consolidate. Maintenance fears that, in an emergency, nobody will be able to find the special part any more. Both concerns are justified. The solution usually lies in routing the bulk of standard orders through one or a few partners and deliberately keeping direct contacts for a small group of highly specialised parts.

Four steps to consolidated procurement

  1. Inventory: Which suppliers are there, how many orders go to each, and which parts are involved?
  2. Cluster: Sort the parts into groups: standard parts, manufacturer-specific spare parts, hard-to-source parts, services.
  3. Pilot: Start by consolidating one group, such as spare parts for one plant, and measure response time, quality and effort.
  4. Roll out: If the pilot holds up, expand step by step. Deliberately keep exceptions for special cases.

Decision guide: which model when?

Situation Recommendation
Many small orders, many manufacturers, high process effort Consolidate through a partner that sources across manufacturers
Critical part with a long lead time and only one manufacturer Safety stock plus a verified alternative
High volumes, standardised goods Dual sourcing for price and supply security
Part available from only one supplier Accept sole sourcing, secure the risk through stock and contract
Plants in several countries Partner with an international network instead of individual local sources

Seven questions to ask a single-source partner

If you consolidate, vet your partner thoroughly. These questions help:

  1. Does the partner buy across manufacturers, or does it only represent a few brands?
  2. How many routes does it know when a part is not available from the manufacturer?
  3. Can it propose technically equivalent alternatives and justify them?
  4. Does it inspect goods itself before they reach you?
  5. Does it have an international set-up in case your demand comes from other regions?
  6. How long has it been on the market, and how financially stable is it?
  7. Are there dedicated contacts who know your plants?

A partner that convinces on all seven questions is more likely to reduce your risk than to increase it.

Three objections you will hear

‘But then we pay a mark-up.’

A sourcing partner earns money from its service, that is true. The counter-calculation is: what do all the supplier set-ups, purchase orders, invoice checks and queries cost you today? The process savings often offset the mark-up. With consolidated volume and good market access, the part price can even fall.

‘Our manufacturer knows the machine best.’

For machine-specific questions, that is true. For standard parts, bought-in components and standard drives in the same machine, it is not. Many components of a plant come from the machine builder's sub-suppliers anyway. You can also source them directly on the market.

‘What if the partner fails?’

That is a fair question. This is why master data and safety stocks of critical parts belong in-house. Then, in an emergency, you can keep working without the partner, just with more effort.

A fourth objection usually comes from the workshop: ‘We want to keep our contact.’ That can be solved too. Dedicated contacts at the sourcing partner who know your plants often replace the direct line to many distributors well. What matters is that maintenance is involved early and not presented with a fait accompli.

Safeguards: single sourcing with a safety net

Even with a good partner, you should not trust blindly. Three simple measures create security:

  • Know your critical parts: For the few parts that stop a plant, keep a safety stock in your own warehouse.
  • Keep data in-house: Part numbers, manufacturers and technical data should be held by you, not just by the supplier.
  • Regular evaluation: Review prices, response times and quality once a year. Not out of mistrust, but out of habit.

How KTB puts this into practice

KTB Europe has worked as a sourcing partner across manufacturers for industrial customers since 1976. For many customers, we are the single point of contact for spare parts, C-materials and components. Behind this one point of contact stands a worldwide supplier network. We obtain quotations from different suppliers, select according to your priorities, whether cost, lead time or other criteria, and inspect the goods in our central warehouse.

If you are considering consolidating your MRO procurement, you will find more about the process on our page on procurement outsourcing . You can submit individual enquiries directly via the page on procurement .

Conclusion

Single sourcing is neither good nor bad. It is a tool. With direct materials, it often increases risk. With MRO, it can reduce risk if the one supplier has many sources. What matters is that you choose the dependency deliberately and secure it.

Would you like to check whether your supplier list can be shortened? Get in touch via our contact page .

Frequently asked questions

What is single sourcing?

Single sourcing means that a company deliberately covers a particular requirement through just one supplier, even though alternatives exist. The aim is lower administrative effort, better terms through consolidated volume and closer collaboration. The downside is dependency, which should be secured through stock, contracts and regular evaluation.

What is the difference between single sourcing and sole sourcing?

With single sourcing, you voluntarily choose one supplier, even though others exist. With sole sourcing, there is only one provider, for example because a manufacturer sells a part exclusively or holds a patent. Single sourcing is therefore a strategy, while sole sourcing is a market reality you have to respond to.

What are the risks of single sourcing?

The biggest risk is the supplier failing, for example through insolvency, capacity bottlenecks or disruptions in its own supply chain. Add creeping price increases without competition and the loss of market knowledge in your own procurement team. You can secure against this with safety stocks of critical parts, your own master data and annual evaluations.

Is single sourcing worthwhile for MRO parts?

Often yes, if the chosen partner buys across manufacturers. You then consolidate the interface, meaning enquiries, purchase orders and invoices, but keep many sources of supply in the background. That lowers process costs without making supply dependent on a single manufacturer. You should also secure critical parts yourself.

MD

About the author

Mica Duarte

Senior Procurement Specialist at KTB Europe with over 15 years of experience in global MRO sourcing and supply chain management.

LinkedIn